The student union voting system needs a shake up

In an earlier issue of Concrete, the front page bore the headline “Union Elections Open to Abuse” and Editor-in-Chief, Geri Scott wrote an article reporting on an error on the UEA SU website and explaining for lay people like myself what that meant.

In case you missed it, here’s what all the kerfuffle was about: due to a technical glitch, students’ records had been reset so that they could vote for representatives in the student union elections for groups within which they themselves did not self-identify. For example, those who did not self-identify as women could, due to the glitch, vote for Women’s Officer, and those who didn’t self-identify as LGBT+ (like myself) could vote for the LGBT+ officer. The elections have since gone ahead.

I honestly had to read about this a couple of times before it sunk in. I understood what had happened but could not for the life of me figure out why it was a mistake. Why was a man being able to vote for the Women’s Officer classed as an accident, rather than the norm?

In my opinion, we are all part of this university and all deserve a say in what goes on. We should be able to choose people for each position within the union who we believe have every student’s best interests at heart. Sound familiar? It should: that’s the basis of democracy. Saying someone isn’t allowed an opinion because they’re male, or they’re not LGBT+, or they’re not disabled…this seems to be running into very dangerous territory in which certain people’s rights are taken away from them because of how they self-define. While I recognise the bye-laws are there for a reason, this particular aspect seems worryingly backward and exclusive.

The concept of a constituency is understandable, and if certain people feel, as some were previously quoted to, that they should not vote in a certain category because they can’t see that it affects them, this is acceptable but in my opinion, a personal decision. I would go on to argue that some decisions can affect you a lot more than you realise.

I am straight. I am also an Irish citizen. This summer, Ireland will hold a referendum on marriage equality to decide whether homosexual couples should be allowed to get married. (A referendum must always be held on changes to Ireland’s written constitution where every citizen gets the chance to vote.) If the union’s bye-laws were put into practise on a national scale in Ireland, I probably wouldn’t be able to vote because I am not homosexual. However, of course I have the right to vote and absolutely intend to utilise it. Just because the issue of gay marriage doesn’t affect me directly, I will still be voting in favour of it not only because I believe it is the right thing to do, but because it might affect me in many serious indirect ways. I don’t want my friends or relatives not to have equal marriage opportunities because I wasn’t allowed to vote. I also feel that if I told you all I don’t intend to vote in the referendum because “I’m not gay so that doesn’t really affect me”, many of you would be judging me harshly for wasting my civil rights and not standing up for what I believe in in order to make the country a better place for all its citizens. You would be right to do so.

Furthermore, how can a union officer expect to gain the support of the entire student body when only certain people were allowed to vote on their election? It should be obvious in this day and age that feminist issues need the support of both men and women, and the LGBT+ community needs, as can be seen in Ireland, the support of the straight community—I use the term need, but there is also of course a case of deserving.

I will end by wishing the newly elected officers for 2015/16 the best of luck in representing us and continuing to make the University the best it can be, academically, socially and in every other way. I would also like to ask them to consider the way we elect officers in the future, and perhaps to ponder how then can guarantee the support of each and every student, by making individuals feel valued and maintaining our democratic rights.


About Author



ONE COMMENT ON THIS POST To “The student union voting system needs a shake up”

  1. The Irish voting thing is a completely false comparison. In student union elections you’re voting for a representative. Why on earth should you, a straight person, be able to decide who best represents LGBT+ people. An LGBT+ officer does not, and should not, represent you as a straight person. They’re there to ensure LGBT+ voices are heard, you shouldn’t be able to have a say in who represents LGBT+ people as a straight person. LGBT+ people don’t need your help in deciding who represents them. Even if you’re incredibly informed on LGBT+ issues, you are not a member of that community, and have no first hand experience of what it is like.

    In comparison, the Irish referendum will be deciding on laws which affect everyone in the country equally. Obviously as a straight person, the chances of you wishing to marry someone of the same gender are small, but if you so wished, at the moment you would not legally be able to. That’s why you have an equal vote in that issue.

    However, this is article is the same entitled stuff that straight, white, able-bodied students come out with every year when they whine about being excluded, because they think they know best for everyone.

January 2021
Latest Comments
  • Avatar
    Favourite song covers
    Ma’am, this is a Wendy’s
  • Avatar Scott B
    Favourite song covers
    Is this author 14 years old with absolutely zero knowledge on music? Has to be. Two out of three songs are irrelevant. Both by shitty bands. Who paid for this?…
  • Avatar theizzin
    Should we mourn GCSE poetry?
    Wonderful article! Very insightful and brilliantly communicated. I wasn't aware of this issue before, but this article has really brought it to light for me. Thank you very much!
About Us

The University of East Anglia’s official student newspaper. Concrete is in print and online.

If you would like to get in touch, email the Editor on Concrete.Editor@uea.ac.uk. Follow us at @ConcreteUEA.